🧵 Why I'm skeptical of companies flaunting massive order books
1/n Been seeing too many stocks rally just because they announced some "record order book." After a few years in the market and some painful lessons, I've learned to dig deeper. Here's what I now look for...
2/n First red flag: Those flashy "MoUs" and "Intent Letters" that never materialize. A renewable company everyone was hyping in 2018 - Half their order book vanished within a year. Look for legally binding contracts
3/n Timeframes matter! A defense supplier whose 5-year order execution meant no meaningful cash flow until year 3. Be extra cautious with orders that take more than 18 months to convert to actual revenue.
4/n Here's what many miss: margins. An infrastructure stock tanked despite "record orders" because they sacrificed profitability to beat competition. Do new orders maintain historical gross margins or if they're just buying revenue.
5/n Client concentration can hurt. An EPC player where 70% of orders came from just two Middle Eastern clients. When payments got delayed, stock crashed. Prefer a diverse order book.
6/n Working capital is the silent killer. A promising mid-cap needed to raise debt for project execution despite their "impressive order book." Check how much cash a company needs to service its orders before celebrating.
7/n Track record matters. I compare what management promised vs delivered in the past 3 years. Found several companies that consistently execute only 60% of their order book guidance. Discount accordingly!
8/n Bottom line: Focus on free cash flow and ROCE, not headline order numbers. As Charlie Munger taught us - incentives drive behavior. Management teams compensated on order book growth will always find ways to inflate it. #investing #StockMarket
