Published: July 15, 2025
67
313
2.4k

Christianity is NOT a pacifist religion Christians are supposed to be pacifists? Just say you know nothing about Christianity The saints and doctors of the Church taught that war is sometimes not only permitted, but a duty Let’s talk about Just and Holy War - a🧵✝️

Image in tweet by Trad West
Image in tweet by Trad West

Let’s begin with a myth: “Christianity means absolute pacifism. War is always evil.” This is FALSE. From the early Church Fathers to the great Doctors like St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas, the Church has always taught that some wars are just, even holy. War is an evil,

Image in tweet by Trad West

The Church does not glorify violence. But she teaches that peace is the fruit of justice, not cowardice - Is 32,17 If tyrants threaten the innocent. If evil crushes the weak. Then Christian men may, and sometimes must, take up arms in defense of the good.

Image in tweet by Trad West
Image in tweet by Trad West

St. Augustine laid the foundations of the doctrine of Just War in the 4th-5th century. In City of God, he wrote: “It is the injustice of the opposing side that lays on the wise man the duty to wage wars.” He taught war can be an act of charity and justice. Just wars are those

Image in tweet by Trad West

According to Augustine, war is not waged for its own sake, but: >to punish evil, >to restore peace, >to defend the innocent. He said: “Peace should be the object of your desire; war should be waged only as a necessity.” This principle would shape Christendom.

Image in tweet by Trad West

Enter St. Thomas Aquinas, the Angelic Doctor. In his Summa Theologiae (II-II, Q.40), he develops Augustine’s insights into a clear doctrine: A Just War requires 3 conditions: >Legitimate authority >Just cause >Right intention These must all be present, otherwise war becomes

Image in tweet by Trad West

1) Legitimate Authority “The authority of the sovereign by whose command the war is to be waged.” No private revenge. No vigilantes. Only those with lawful public office can declare war. Like kings or rulers tasked with the common good. This preserves order.

Image in tweet by Trad West

2) Just Cause “Those who are attacked must deserve it on account of some fault.” This means war must be defensive or punitive: >Repelling invaders (Reconquista) >Rescuing victims of injustice (Charlemagne saving the Pope) >Punishing grave wrongs (The Crusades)

Image in tweet by Trad West

3) Right Intention “The belligerents must intend the advancement of good, or the avoidance of evil.” Even if authority and cause are just, a lust for blood or vengeance corrupts it. A true Just War must be aimed at restoring peace and defeating evil.

Image in tweet by Trad West

But Aquinas goes even further. He teaches that war can be meritorious, even holy, if fought for the glory of God and defense of the Faith. “Those who wage war in obedience to the divine command, do not sin.” This is the origin of Holy War.

Image in tweet by Trad West

True peace is only found among the good and in goodness; the peace of the wicked is only apparent This destroys modern pacifist errors: not all peace is just, and avoiding conflict at all costs may preserve the dominion of evil.

Image in tweet by Trad West

Just War is not a contradiction of Christ’s peace but its defense. St. Augustine said: “Even peace itself may be a weapon.” And St. Thomas adds: "Those who wage war justly aim at peace, not vengeance.” (Summa Theol., II-II, q.40, a.1, ad 2)

Image in tweet by Trad West
Image in tweet by Trad West

Holy War is not a Crusade of conquest. It is the defense of: >the Church, >the sacraments, >the Christian people, and their rights >and God’s law. When these are under threat, Christian princes are bound by justice and charity to defend them.

Image in tweet by Trad West

Christ Himself is not a pacifist. He drove out the money changers with a whip - Jn 2,15 He called His apostles to be fishers of men, but His Book of Revelation shows Him returning as a rider on a white horse, with a sword (Rev 19), waging war on evil.

Image in tweet by Trad West

Those who quote “Put away your sword” (Mt 26,52) to argue for pacifism forget: Jesus rebuked Peter not for using a sword, but for acting without authority. “He who draws the sword without permission of a lawful power sins,” says Augustine. The Bible never condemns war

Image in tweet by Trad West

Francisco Suárez, a theologian, said: “War is not intrinsically evil, but can be honest and indispensable, when waged to restore justice and protect the innocent.” This is echoed in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (n. 2265–2266).

Image in tweet by Trad West

Even the saints fought. >St. Joan of Arc led armies to defend Christian France. >St. Louis IX led Crusades to recover the Holy Land. >St. Fernando III of Castile freed Spain from Islam by the sword, and was canonized. Holiness and heroism are not opposites.

Image in tweet by Trad West
Image in tweet by Trad West

So, no, Christianity is not pacifist religion It is a religion of peace through justice. It calls men to meekness, not cowardice. To fortitude, not brutality. To defend, not to dominate. Sometimes, the sword is needed to protect the Cross.

Image in tweet by Trad West

As St. Thomas says: “The aim of the just warrior is peace.” But when peace is shattered by injustice, the Christian must not hide. He must stand & fight. With sword in one hand and rosary in the other. Non nobis, Domine, sed nomini tuo da gloriam.

Image in tweet by Trad West

If you want to support our work check out our merch: http://tradwest.net You get some quality clothing while helping us grow the page and produce better content!

Image in tweet by Trad West

Share this thread

Read on Twitter

View original thread

Navigate thread

1/20