Published: September 3, 2025
192
1.9k
4.8k

I see ID cards are back. Many years ago, I had the inenvious task of being one of the architects of one part of last attempt in the 2000s - Enrolling the population. I felt physically sick going into work, and left the company soon after. A wise choice considering what

@ChiefPieEater ♾ What if there was a power cut, how would we access anything???

@gniffer55174980 It would be 'highly available' in other words, a duplicated (maybe triplicated) system so if one computer goes down, the others take over. However, this is ££££, and so the pressure will be on to pay its way. Again, it ain't for stopping boats.

@ChiefPieEater Thanks for taking the time to explain how the mechanics of this “wouldn’t” work 👍🏻

@yelwap27 Even twenty years or so on, it would be expensive, and flaws easily built in from day one. Not to mention the running costs, so it would have to have multiple use cases.

@ChiefPieEater Brilliant explanation!!

@PaulTaylorIeng You are welcome.

@ChiefPieEater I hope you realise many high functioning societies have ID card; Singapore has had one gif decades. The British introduce ID in Hong Kong since no one even remember when. The tool itself is not necessarily bad/ evil. It is all on how it is used.

@sc_campo125 They do, and they still have crime. Even high trust societies like those.

@ChiefPieEater How much would it cost to implement this today? And what is the probability it would be delivered in this Parliament?

@Smallcapscat1 Easily over £5bn... depends on who gets access. RIPA must be a strong contender as cover for usage.

@ChiefPieEater And the minute it does get issued, it'll be a) faked and b) hacked. As you say, fortunately it would take years, if ever. Government and successful IT projects don't exactly go together.

@SarahDixon18 My fear is they will go cheap and expand the current passport systems. Again, migrants already get an ID from that to access Government benefits. My suspicions are it will be for access to banking, government and local government benefits and services.

@ChiefPieEater Unenvious

@harrydemko Yes, v tired on a Eurostar, thanks.

@ChiefPieEater Still got mine!

Image in tweet by Warspite 🇬🇧

@mjsimpsonfilms Yep, same chip as the current passport system. The biometrics trial was a bit of a joke, retinal didn't work, and we now have facial recognition which did not exist in the 2000s. Fingerprints are a problem, and full hand scanners are now available - that was military tech 20

@ChiefPieEater I'm confused, everyone registered BORN IN THE UK is sent a National Insurance number just before their 16th birthday. Others seeking legal work are required to apply for one. SO the rest consist of illegal migrants, foreign-born residents in the UK who have never worked legally

@casapinos Great point, however, that system is linked to HMRC, and inter-departmental working in Government is slow, political, and most management teams are criminally incompetent. The tech will be 30+ years old too.

@ChiefPieEater Difficult to take this post seriously if you don’t have a name and eat all the pies.

@William59600094 Easy for you to say, Dick. Take at face value, it's cost you £0.

@ChiefPieEater @Beautyon_ But it is necessary for the programable Digital Currency, the boot on the human face forever, therefore the captured UK has been chosen as the guinea pig.

@ChiefPieEater It’s not even the cost, or even all those flaws. At the moment most of these illegals have fake documents or no right to be here and are doing everything under the table. An ID card won’t stop that. Most of our systems don’t talk to one another so some can get jobs, NI numbers,

@ChiefPieEater I live full time on a boat… no fixed abode. I have to move my boat every two weeks. It makes life difficult enough but there are workarounds. Only the bank, dvla, and car insurance need a fixed address. I have to ‘borrow’ one for those companies. I can see this ID thing becoming

@ChiefPieEater Look up one gov accts. the foundation is already here. Yes it’ll take years to build in it but let’s hope reform are in by then to cancel it.

@ChiefPieEater It’s not a card. It’s the onegov acct

Share this thread

Read on Twitter

View original thread

Navigate thread

1/26