2\ Positives: The infamous GHF would be abolished since the plan says aid will only be distributed by groups "not associated in any manner with either party" (GHF is an IDF front). Full suspension of "all military operations" (e.g. bombing) & immediate end to the war

3\ Trump's plan now talks about decommissioning instead of disarmament. There's a major difference; the latter connotes surrender, whereas decommissioning is gradual, tied to a political process & includes reintegration of militants into security sector https://ecfr.eu/article/decomm...

4\ IDF withdrawal, albeit staged, is an important element, especially when it's paired with a clear "no occupation or annexation" qualifier (i.e. end of Ben Gvir & Smotrich's dream to recolonize Gaza). Gazans will be "encourage to stay" & anyone leaving can return whenever.

5\ An earlier version of Trump's plan had a clear reference to "deradicalize the populations" (i.e. Israelis & Palestinians) acknowledging the widespread extremism in Israel Now there's only a reference to changing "mindsets & narratives" of both peoples towards peace (how?)

6\ Negatives: No release of Marwan Barghouti & other top leaders. Only 250 out of 300 life sentenced Palestinians would be released, giving Israel a veto over any name whose release would revitalize the Palestinian movement. Nothing on immediate provision of housing solutions

7\ The Palestinian Authority's return to Gaza is contingent on "reforms" in line with Trump's 2020 plan. This means dropping the ICC lawsuit against Israel (hard to imagine how the PA can do this without losing its remaining legitimacy). Board of Peace chaired by Trump & Blair;

8\ The IDF staged withdrawal lines in the map are NOT the "agreed upon" In both the Jan 2025 ceasefire plan & the Witkoff plan, the agreed lines were that Israel withdraws immediately to a buffer zone of only 900 meters all around Gaza, as opposed to the current map giving

9\ IDF withdrawal is paired with "standards, milestones, & timeframes". But that is made contingent upon an endless & elusive "demilitarization" goal & is conditioned on Gaza being "properly secure from any resurgent terror threat"; which would allow the IDF to occupy forever &

10\ Israel will be forever in control of the Rafah crossing, since leaving the "security buffer zone" is conditioned on an unfulfillable goal of eliminating Palestinian armed resistance entirely (As long as there's occupation there would be resistance) This means Israel controls

11\ Trump's Plan talks about "horizon" for "peaceful & prosperous co-existence", which means no commitment to the 2-state solution Hard to imagine how decommissioning could happen without a clear path with a clear timeframe towards Palestinian statehood

12\ Netanyahu inserted enough loopholes (e.g. unliveable withdrawal lines, no real prospect of the IDF ever leaving Gaza) to get Hamas to reject the deal then blame them for it. It's his classic move in previous ceasefire talks to buy time for genocide! https://x.com/DropSiteNews/sta...

13\ Most dangerous loophole is: if Hamas rejects this take-it-or-leave-it proposal, Israel & the US would turn to establishing international forces in "terror-free areas" This is a clear reference to the ISIS-linked Abu Shabab gang's concentration camp in South-Eastern Rafah &

14\ Even if Hamas accepts the plan & fulfils all of it, there is ZERO guarantee that Netanyahu will abide by any of it or that Trump would pressure him to. Last time Israel signed a ceasefire agreement under Trump in Jan 2025, Netanyahu reneged on almost all of it (e.g. never

15\ Israeli captives in Gaza are the only actual "insurance policy" or guarantee that Israel can be pressured into honoring any agreement But Trump's plan demands releasing every single one of them within 3 days. Which means, Netanyahu would have no obligation to fulfil anything

@muhammadshehad2 "in addition to other international institutions not associated in any manner with either party." Doesn't sound like abolishing GHF, as it was presented as american initiative.

@clauci2nd "In any manner" means GHF (Israeli media reported that Netanyahu was trying to remove this part). GHF's main client is the IDF

@muhammadshehad2 This plan may seem like progress, but beneath it all, the roots of occupation grow deep. Netanyahu’s past shows a constant drive to erase Palestinian identity. A mask of peace, while the truth is clear: Gaza suffers, and the violence won’t stop.

@muhammadshehad2 If indeed this was a peace deal that United States wishes to sponsor then they ought to propose it for adoption at the UN. Let all member States debate the issue and alter the wordings should they deem fit and elect whom they feel would be fair into the so called "Board of Peace"

@muhammadshehad2 always read the hebrew press for their true words

@muhammadshehad2 The ethnic cleansing, the killing of Palestinians, the demolition of their homes, and the theft of their land is an ongoing process that has not stopped since the Zionist project began. If this continues, then Netanyahu's, sorry, Trump's plan has no meaning.

@muhammadshehad2 Unless the UN Security Council sanction it this grubby little collaboration has zero legal basis. Politicians don’t just redraw borders between themselves and bypass UN Charters. In that case Putin Xi Jimping announce tomorrow their peace Board over Malaysia? It’s BS..

@muhammadshehad2 This so called “peace plan” is a deception and a trap for Hamas. It demands Hamas to release all the Zionist POWs, which is their only leverage, in first 72 hours as the first step. After this Netanyahu and Trump would simply shift the goal post and continue the genocide in Gaza.

@muhammadshehad2 I realise that Palestine cant be seen to have gained anything from this but this is just another land grab. The open air prison has just got smaller, there is no infrastructure remaining, there is no open borders, there is no port or means to trade

@muhammadshehad2 Trump,whose country participates actively in the genocide,would be at the head of a so-called "peace council".In which world can support for genocide be a "defender of peace"?This dystopian logic also applies toTony Blair, responsible for hundreds of thousands of deaths in Iraq⬇️

@muhammadshehad2 As long as the plan starts by releasing all hostages within 72 hours, hence no leverage, it shouldn't be taken seriously and everything is moot When they agree to a gradual release of hostages over at least 6 months, then the ceasefire can be trusted

@muhammadshehad2 It’s better. But the buffer zone belongs on the Israeli side. They should release all of the Palestinian prisoners held without charges (all 10k or so of them). It should include a right to some kind of ID and rebuilding the airport port so the people can come and go.

@muhammadshehad2 Another Oslo only this time the Arabs are taking Mubarak's place and asking the resistance to sign it.

@muhammadshehad2 And no plan to stop the blockade and occupation, it will still be an open air concentration camp with frequent bombing.

@muhammadshehad2 Good review & already Netanyahu has given evidence to your criticism by stating there will never be a Stare of Palestine & the IDF won’t leave UN stability & ICJ validity tested by an autocratic & Zionist who continue 2 commit Genocide for the 24th month. Revised edition needed

@muhammadshehad2 In a nutshell as seen by Zionists who are celebrating the plan.

@muhammadshehad2 the plan is: instead of 'erasure' it will be legitimizing lack of self determination for palestinians forever

@muhammadshehad2 There is no 'deal'; there is ONLY a loophole. This is 'Israel'. There are no deals. There never will be. Every so-called 'deal' is a trap. Take this as a solid given. FOREVER.

@muhammadshehad2 We'll create a mandate system & logic but we'll refrain from calling it that because it's not that cool anymore

@muhammadshehad2 And there you have it. Netanyahu admits he has no intention on following through on the plan. Again, we manage to spectacularly embarrass ourselves. These people keep saying day in and day out: they want to annhilate the Palestinians... https://x.com/DropSiteNews/sta...

@muhammadshehad2 https://x.com/dropsitenews/sta...