Published: October 16, 2025
461
77
948

When Mamdani first won his primary and most of the left were celebrating, I tried very hard not to rain on their parade and said that while it was possible for his victory to be good for the movement, it would depend on how he led. I’m at the point now where I need him to lose.

Promising you will have Zionists in your administration, not even limited to liberal Zionists, is not how you expose the system and mobilize workers to oppose it. This is just post-genocide rehabilitation of a genocidal party, and actively harmful.

Fuck Zohran Mamdani. Him saying at the beginning of his campaign that his purpose was to improve or restore the Democratic Party should have been an immediate dealbreaker for everyone who believes in ending capitalism.

The moral of the story is that, contrary to popular belief, candidates who call themselves “socialists” winning elections is not necessarily good for popularizing socialism, and can actually make socialism look like dogshit.

@seizethebanks Oh wow. Not that. Cuomo is a disease. Even if Zohran isn't a cure.

@makebasmoon I don’t want Cuomo to get elected, but I also can’t bear the idea of Mamdani getting rewarded for his snakery. I wish they could both lose.

@seizethebanks So now you’re arguing scorched earth, as if we don’t have to suffer through this in order to get to your fairytale ending. Aligning your approval from a purity test from a successfully navigated hostile Fox News interview is naive. Politics. One base understands, one doesn’t

@seizethebanks AOC & Mamdani are dangling food in front of people's faces, people who are STARVING for freedom & real change. Only for them to find out the food is poisoned! The feast will never come from within a capitalist & imperialist party. We cannot take a plate passed from bloodied hands

@seizethebanks this is so insane and regressive. you’re actually saying you’d rather have the most progressive candidate we’ve had in YEARS lose to cuomo. purity politics and moral grandstanding is killing us.

@seizethebanks @transjewtalian Yup. He's going to keep bending and getting bogged down in bullshit and just become another Krysten Sinema or some shit. He is underestimating how violently they oppose the left, and therefore how much Stalins are necessary.

@seizethebanks Agreed. At this point I feel like it’s psyops for Mamdani to win. Victory would give voters the impression that the two party system works and that centrist Democrats now ‘accept’ ‘progressive/socialist’ politics just to cajole people back into the status quo

@seizethebanks One of the fundamental problems with people believing that a politician will bring socialism is a fundamental misunderstanding of socialist theory! Socialism seeks the abolition of the state-- not to work with it. Socialism is also something workers do-- not a government

@seizethebanks then who do u want. cause it’s gonna be one of the two and id argue mamdani is still miles ahead of cuomo. are you just going to refuse to vote?

@seizethebanks My rebuttal to this is the exact same as what we've been explaining to the Right: He's running for fucking mayor of a city not president, calm down he's not setting foreign policy what is wrong with yall

@seizethebanks you can criticize him and still recognize that electing him is progress. "let the fascists keep winning bc i just, like, totally can't even look at him anymore 😣" isn't a productive political stance. elect him, just don't be satisfied with him.

Image in tweet by Brenton 🇵🇸

@seizethebanks Why do leftists always end up wanting to lose elections?

@seizethebanks You can have your critiques of a leader - but needing him to lose? Just allergic to victory for the cause, eh? He said he would arrest Bibi, has the chance of being the biggest success for a socialist in this country in a long time, let's take a smaller W over a harder L.

@seizethebanks Literally no way for a candidate to be good enough for you, so it seems. There's hundreds of "left" politicians that deserve criticism before Zohran. If he's knocking out all career mayors as a 34 year old socialist, there's something good about him. Your criteria = We never win

@seizethebanks You've lost the plot on this one. You don't get to just end capitalism without winning, you don't get to just end capitalism with one NYC Mayoral race. It's a million step road and you take it one step at a time. Grow up.

@seizethebanks Pretending that we can win without some level of comprise is loser shit that will only end with failure. I so sick of the lefties that have this stupid fucking reaction the SECOND someone that isnt them looks like they might win.

@seizethebanks Teaching the working poor of NYC a lesson by making their lives objectively worse under Cuomo because Zohran has some issues which need to be addressed. "Marxist" btw. Critical Support, does anyone remember this?

@seizethebanks why do you need him to lose when he is going to raise the material needs of working class people. On the imperialist critiques I understand where you are coming from (the liberal zionist appeasement). His focus on working class people in New York is a test case on national scale

@seizethebanks yeah when i realized his rhetoric was going a little soft i decided i also wanted benjamin netanyahu’s personal lawyer to win. i can tell you care so deeply about palestine and don’t view politics through the lens of a team sport

@seizethebanks Thats not how politics work here. Unfortunate reality is that ours is a system of A or B, and B-Cuomo-is exponentially worse. You hate zionists yet you would rather have the man who is the attorny for the king of zionists than the guy who you *think* *might* work with zionists.

@seizethebanks Do you know who the opposition is or are you just doing lazy ass posturing to look good

@seizethebanks ah, finally. i've long awaited this moment, when the left is ascendant enough that it begins to sprout its funniest posters: the left winger whose only goal in life is to make sure the left never wins

@seizethebanks I'll bite. Of what benefit is Mamdani losing?

@seizethebanks If Mamdani is now pissing off commies then maybe now I would actually want him to win LOL

@seizethebanks Right Brenton, so let’s elect a literal sex pest and BENJAMIN NETANYAHU’S LAWYER to represent our city then…

@seizethebanks This is why we lose. No broad coalition building. No acknowledgement of what it actually takes to win elections. Just shooting ourselves in the foot before we even get a chance at moving the needle.

@seizethebanks I think I’d rather NYC get universal free pre-k and childcare than vote against a guy because he correctly acknowledge some finance department deputy went on birthright.

@seizethebanks I’m at the point where I need you guys to start caring about your neighbors in your local communities more than foreign affairs that municipal leaders have zero control over. This purity test for one foreign policy issue is INSANE and I’m convinced it’s just performance art now

@seizethebanks >marxist-leninist >is against every rising and potential left wing figure and movement today McCarthy approves you guys.

@seizethebanks dawg what are you talking about "I want Andrew Cuomo to be Mayor instead so more poor people can suffer" is a dogshit take

@seizethebanks People like you give actual leftists a bad name. I used to scoff when liberals would say leftists hate actually winning and then I started seeing this shit. Mamdani is one of the most left leaning politicians in the country and wanting him to lose to a right wing rapist is nuts.

@seizethebanks This is more pathetic than any Cuomo supporter post I’ve seen and that’s saying something. Just absolutely terminally addicted to losing and never making any progress. Leftists take enough L’s without spineless shit like this.

Share this thread

Read on Twitter

View original thread

Navigate thread

1/37