@roisinmurphy I loved your vocals on HBMS’s The Truth. Shame you’re now a twat. Hostile environments that make people feel unsafe can lead to those people hiding who they are. There aren’t less trans people. There are more scared trans people.

@proper_jobbing What about a balanced, caring and safe environment. That’s all I’m calling for.

@roisinmurphy Is it tho? https://x.com/roisinmurphy/sta...

@proper_jobbing Yes

@roisinmurphy “It was never real” totally screams “balanced, caring and safe environment”.

@proper_jobbing I thought so.

@roisinmurphy You think telling trans people they were “never real” is creating “a balanced, caring and safe environment”?

@proper_jobbing Yes much safer to accept themselves than to pursue something unattainable via pseudo- medical experiments.

@roisinmurphy If someone said “homosexuality was never real” would you laugh at them saying that what they wanted was “a balanced, caring and safe environment”?

@proper_jobbing Yes I would. But that’s exactly what’s happening in gender clinics!

@roisinmurphy What are you saying is happening? People are claiming that homosexuality was never real?

@proper_jobbing You know exactly what I’m saying

@roisinmurphy @proper_jobbing She's suggesting "gay" people are being told they're not gay and actually they're trans and should transition. It's a lovely little conspiracy theory those with a few skeletons in their closet like to push around and makes about as much sense as the Flat Earth.

@tweeting_keith @proper_jobbing They are blocking puberty before the even think about their sexuality.

@roisinmurphy @proper_jobbing And you'd know, wouldn't you, because you're in those consultation rooms and party to those private conversations, aren't you? Keep your beak out of other people's lives and at least try and be half decent at your chosen profession. Couple of decades since your last "hit", no?

@tweeting_keith @proper_jobbing Keith have you read this? You might want to widen your scope a touch. Just a suggestion.

@roisinmurphy @proper_jobbing No, namely because Hannah is from Planet TERF. Irony being that, if you folk get your way, you'll both be the kind of women stopped from entering toilets. Can I suggest you actually talk to some trans folk? Or are you just hoping GB News viewers will start buying your albums?

@tweeting_keith @proper_jobbing She’s a brilliant and thorough journalist. Don’t care who buys my albums, I make them to please myself. I not cynical or a snob.

@roisinmurphy @tweeting_keith It’s funny how you ran away from your original point, that trans people “weren’t real”, and made the discussion about something else. Telling. I think, deep down, you know how awful what you said was.

@proper_jobbing @tweeting_keith Trans ideology is not real and is dangerous and corrupt. It must be dismantled. That do for you?

@roisinmurphy @tweeting_keith Gender dysphoria is real, was first diagnosed over 100 years ago, and the treatment is transitioning.

@proper_jobbing @tweeting_keith No debate!

@roisinmurphy @proper_jobbing @tweeting_keith You are correct in that there is no such thing as trans ideology. Some people are just trans. I'm bisexual, there's no ideology behind me being the way that I am, the same as with trans people. They exist. They have existed throughout history. To deny that is to deny reality.

@roisinmurphy @proper_jobbing @tweeting_keith "Trans ideology" is barely one step removed from "the gay agenda" you sound crazy roisin